Best Overall
WaterHog Boxwood 23x36
- Size: 23 x 36 in
- Material: PET fiber, rubber backing
- Thickness: 0.38 in
- Water Capacity: Up to 1 gal per sq yd
Pros
- Covers a full 23 x 36 inch threshold
- Holds water in the pile instead of tracking it
- Vacuums, hoses clean, air-dries quickly
- Pile and color hold up to traffic
Cons
- Highest price in this roundup
Twenty-three inches by thirty-six is the size that changed our minds about doormats. A 17 x 29 mat covers a doorway; this one covers the traffic — two people coming in at once, a dog cutting the corner, the swing of the door itself. At 0.38 inches it still sits low enough that we stopped thinking about clearance after the first day, and the rubber back keeps the whole thing flat instead of rucking up at the corners.
Water is where it separates from the cheaper mats. The top is a stiff PET fiber set into deep grooves with a rubber border around the edge, built to hold up to a gallon of water per square yard rather than let it run across the floor. What that gives you is a mat that never squelches: rain goes into the pile, your shoes come out drier, and the floor inside stays dry. When it gets grim, vacuum it, hose it, and stand it up to air.
It also wears better than anything else in this group. The pile stayed dense and the pattern kept its color, and the mat never shed fibers onto the step the way cheaper synthetics can. The fiber is made with up to 90 percent recycled material, which is a bonus rather than the reason to buy. One detail to plan around: the listed size carries a 3 percent manufacturing variance, so do not design a millimeter-tight fit against a door frame.
So this is our pick, with one caveat. It is the premium mat here, and a sheltered porch with dry feet does not need it — the DII or the WeatherMAX covers that job for a lot less money. What you are paying for is a mat that handles a wet, gritty threshold and still looks like something you chose on purpose, and on that measure nothing else here matched it.